The Truth About Stan Lee

The Truth About Stan Lee




Jack Kirby and Stan Lee

Stan Lee passed away the other day. With his passing came an avalanche of news reports and tributes to his career that ranged from mostly inaccurate to wholly inaccurate.

Anyone who knows me will tell you that I have always been staunchly on team Kirby/Ditko when it comes to who created the Marvel Universe. But if you ask me who should get the credit for the success of Marvel Comics, the answer is Stan Lee.

If you put aside his hucksterism, his shameless self-promotion and his dubious depiction of his role in the creation of these immortal characters, Stan Lee was one hell of an editor. He was the best comics editor ever to wield a blue pencil. 

He may not have played the role attributed to him (mostly thanks to him) by mainstream media in the genesis of these characters but he sure knew what to do with them. One of the famous nails in the coffin of Jack Kirby's 60s tenure at Marvel was Stan Lee's appropriation of a character Jack had casually tossed into the epic Galactus trilogy in The Fantastic Four. In Jack's mind, the Silver Surfer was merely a drone, a soulless tool whose only purpose was to find planets for his master to consume.

 Lee gave him a name, Norrin Radd, and developed him into a character of Shakespearean pathos, who sacrificed his humanity to save his homeworld and his beloved Shalla Bal. Stan's initial run on The Silver Surfer solo comic may not have been commercially successful but it was intellectually ambitious and the first indication of what the medium could become in a literary sense.

As an editor, Stan established the overarching moral philosophy of Marvel. He reined in Kirby's often out of control imagination which, admittedly, sometimes got in the way of coherent storytelling. 

But Stan wasn't just a strong editor when it came to writing and the editorial direction of a comic, he was the de facto art director. Stan held the books under his purview to a very high standard visually. Just peruse the many dozens of issues of The Jack Kirby Collector to see countless examples of covers and page sequences that were rejected by Stan because of awkward perspective, lack of energy or confusing panel sequences.

 Stan Lee is portrayed by his detractors as some kind of self-aggrandizing pimp who took money on the lecture circuit on the backs of the work of others and, to some extent, he was. After he handed the editorial reins of Marvel to "Rascally" Roy Thomas in the early 70s, he devoted most of his time to promoting Marvel Comics and himself.

 But in the 60s he was George Martin, making sense of all the creative chaos being thrown his way by two visionary artists. He was hands on and he knew what he was doing. Sadly, Stan Lee's true and essential role in the story of Marvel often gets lost in the argument.

Eric Sandberg


 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Jackshit For Christmas

Image
  Concert Review 9th Annual Jackshit Christmas Show  McCabe's Guitar Shop December 14, 2018 https://www.jackshittheband.com/band.php https://www.mccabes.com/ https://www.mhopus.org/ I can honestly say that, until the evening of December 14th, 2018, I didn't know Jackshit. I was invited by Mike Berman (my erstwhile partner in this little opining venture) who could scarcely contain his excitement at securing two tickets...something about Elvis' rhythm section, some Scottish guy and guest stars? Heck, I'd go see William Hung if it was at McCabe's Guitar Shop in Santa Monica. I've never once looked at my watch during a show at McCabe's. Now it's the morning after and boy do I know Jackshit. You ignorant fools! I've been a devoted fan for years! I have all their albums! Look, one is signed by all three of them! But seriously, folks, there is nothing serious about Jackshit except for their astonishing musical ability and their obvious sh...
Read more

Album Review-Trevor Horn Reimagines The Eighties

Image
By 1981 Trevor Horn had accomplished a lot as a musician. while playing bass in Tina Charles backing band, Horn recruited two of its members, Geoff Downes and Bruce Wooley, to do a 'Toto' and form a studio band called Buggles to record their own songs.  After they wrote the song "Video Killed The Radio Star" together, Wooley left to form The Camera Club with, then unknowns, Thomas Dolby and Matthew Seligman and recorded his own version of the song. Of course the slickly produced version by Buggles was an international hit, the video for which launched MTV almost two years later. Then, in one of the oddest career left-turns ever documented, Buggles were tapped to replace the departed Jon Anderson and Rick Wakeman in Yes. This lineup recorded Drama , a strange album that mixed heavy metal with new wave, electronica and progressive rock. Trevor Horn (foreground) and Geoff Downes in their Buggles days A world tour followed which was successful in America but...
Read more

Two Depressing Christmas Songs that Don't Suck

Image
Essay: Two Depressing Christmas Songs that Don't Suck It's become fashionable to complain about Christmas music - it starts too soon, it's too syrupy, and now it's even sexist and rapey . For example, Robyn Hitchcock, who's one of the "patron saints" of this site, recently Tweeted: Part of the problem is that it's a holiday that we're all expected to like, but we perceive differently. Many people don't even observe Christmas as a holiday, religious or secular, while some seem to really believe it's "the most wonderful time of the year" - kind of like there are people who think that Disneyland is the "happiest place on Earth". (I think there's a large overlap in the later groups... for them, Christmas at Disneyland must be the closest thing to an ecstatic experience...) Then there are those of us - and there are many - who have a complex relationship with the holiday. I come from a non-religious background, wi...
Read more